Workplace Wellbeing

Engagement Isn't Just an HR Problem: The $8.9 Trillion Reason Why Everyone from the CEO to Interns Should be Paying Attention

Our Chief People Officer is sharing insights from Gallup’s 2024 State of the Global Workplace report, emphasizing the role of leadership and culture in creating meaningful work experiences for everyone.

Written by
photo authr
Karishma Patel Buford
Chief People Officer, Spring Health
Clinically reviewed by
photo authr
A man using an iPad for work

Jump to section

    Have you ever thought about how the quality of our time at work impacts our overall existence?

    We spend 13 consecutive years of our lives working—4,821 total days—which is more than the combined time we spend on romance, exercise, holidays, and school.

    Yet, how do we measure the quality of this formative chunk of our lives? Are we simply clock-watching, disconnected from our tasks, or are we finding purpose and meaning in our work and, therefore, in our lives?

    I had the honor of speaking at Gallup’s launch event for the 2024 State of the Global Workplace report, where Gallup CEO Jon Clifton raised this thought-provoking question. It's an issue that deserves our attention, and we’ll explore it using insights from the report.

    As we’re thinking about engagement, let's keep this question in mind: Are your employees just going through the motions at work, or are they connecting with something larger than themselves?

    Engagement is about well-being

    Engagement isn't just about productivity, but also the quality of our experiences. Employees actively disengaged at work often report lower well-being than unemployed people. They experience higher levels of stress, anger, worry, and loneliness.

    This highlights something crucial: job satisfaction deeply impacts our emotional and mental health. It's not just about individual happiness, though. The economic implications are enormous.

    The cost of low engagement is high

    One thing that stands out in Gallup’s report is that disengagement costs the economy $8.9 trillion, an astounding 9% of global GDP. It’s less surprising to read that 62% of the world’s working population struggles with engagement.

    Other findings include that:

    • Only 23% of employees feel truly engaged at work
    • 15% are actively disengaged, potentially undermining their colleagues and companies
    • Young employees' well-being has taken a significant hit
    • Just 34% of workers report thriving in their overall well-being
    • Over half (52%) are either watching for or actively seeking new jobs

    But there’s a silver lining. Engagement is a critical factor in life satisfaction and hope for the future. When we're connected to our work, we're more likely to feel optimistic about what lies ahead. Work can be intrinsic to a better life.

    These numbers paint a clear picture: employee engagement isn't just a workplace issue—it's a global economic and well-being challenge that affects us all.

    Evolving values have changed the workplace

    It’s impossible to discuss employee engagement without recognizing how much the value proposition has been almost completely redefined over the past few years.

    As work evolves—many people can work anywhere—employees have new leverage in seeking work that aligns with their values.

    When talking to customers as Chief People Officer at Spring Health, I always find it useful to consider Daniel Pink’s intrinsic motivators framework, especially in regards to younger people entering the workforce.

    Now more than ever, employees seek purpose, mastery, autonomy, meaning, and fulfillment in their work lives. 

    On a personal level, they are seeking support for the whole person. They don’t want to walk into work and feel like an interchangeable automaton, but want to feel seen, heard, humanized, and valued. This is key to the evolution of work.

    Leadership and engagement go hand in hand

    Imagine a CEO who scrutinizes engagement data as closely as financial statements. That's a leader who truly "gets it." 

    In today's workplace, employees are increasingly asking, does the C-suite genuinely care about our well-being? That’s what employers need to feel—as if they are part of something meaningful, a job where being fully engaged is one end of an arrangement in which mutual care is prioritized.

    This shift isn't going anywhere. It's a fundamental change in how we view work. Job seekers now prioritize organizations where leadership is deeply invested in people strategy. 

    When I was a clinician still seeing patients 15 years ago, I would have been surprised by the idea that employers should play a central role in their employees’ mental health. I'm amazed that such a significant shift has occurred in just a few years.

    Mental health and well-being support is no longer a perk—it's a prerequisite. Companies without robust well-being strategies are left behind in the talent race.

    Engagement is a systemic issue

    While HR often leads the charge on engagement, the roots of disengagement run deeper. Think about those days when you feel de-energized at work. It's usually not just one thing, but a combination of factors:

    • An inability to use your strengths
    • Friction in getting things done
    • Broken processes and cross-functional collaboration
    • Difficult relationships

    These systemic issues can't be solved by HR alone. They require a top-down approach, with C-suite support empowering HR leaders and managers to address processes, practices, and communication.

    The key is recognizing that engagement isn't just an HR issue—it's a company-wide challenge that impacts every aspect of organizational success.

    For sustainable solutions, look to culture

    Momentary perks in the workplace can be great for employees, but burnout results from death by a thousand cuts, daily friction, the ensuing stress from that friction, and a lack of deep well-being support.

    A CEO I used to work with would always say that culture is about how you feel on a Sunday night going to work the next morning. 

    Ask yourself, what is the daily experience like for employees? Addressing engagement requires long-term, sustainable change regarding the employee experience.

    Managers are key drivers of culture

    Regarding mental health, managers have a similar impact on employees as a spouse or partner. This is where you see a causal process in which leadership is so important.

    When organizational leadership ensures that managers have the resources they need and are themselves supported and trained, they can better be engaged and set the tone for their teams.

    Gallup has found that in best-practice organizations, three-fourths of managers are engaged, and 70% of the variance in team engagement is determined solely by the manager.

    Engagement requires both individual and organizational approaches 

    At Spring Health, we have a twofold solution: SpringLife, which provides individual mental health support such as coaching, therapy, and medication management, and SpringWorks, which is focused on giving managers the support they need. 

    Managers need direction around navigating employee burnout, engagement, and mental health challenges, including:

    • How to work through low team morale
    • Navigating complex situations
    • How to provide support for someone experiencing a mental health challenge
    • Onsite manager support, such as real time advice for dealing with specific issues

    When we talk to customers, we realize there is just not enough support for managers, which is reflected in the rate at which they feel burnt out. 

    Measuring engagement is about understanding thriving

    As part of Spring Health’s Employee Experience strategy, we measure engagement through the lens of employee thriving. Our thriving framework is very particular. We measure how energized, empowered, and inspired people feel at work. 

    The way we think about our measuring engagement goals is to move from broad engagement surveys to specific measurement points of what we know people need to feel engaged, do their best work, be productive, and stay with their organization.

    One of our mottos is “science will win,” which is why we incorporate research-based best practices into our surveys to get the best engagement data. Engagement doesn’t have to be an intangible problem, especially as it’s connected with well-being.

    The path to engagement

    There's no magic formula for employee engagement and well-being. Before taking on the Chief People Officer role at Spring Health, I had the same role at a financial technology company. What I did there was completely different from what I do now, but there are fundamentals that translate across industries.

    Data is your compass. It can guide you to solutions that fit your culture and people. You don’t have to do what everyone else does—let your data lead the way.

    Organizations that embrace this approach are reaping the rewards through higher retention rates and a more engaged workforce. It's a challenging journey, but the destination—a thriving, productive workplace—is well worth the effort.

    Prioritize team morale to significantly raise employee well-being and engagement, and create a reimagined workplace where everyone thrives.

    About the Author
    photo authr
    Karishma Patel Buford
    Chief People Officer, Spring Health

    Karishma Patel Buford is the Chief People Officer at Spring Health, where she focuses on talent acquisition, onboarding, learning and development, total rewards, DE&I, organizational development, and culture initiatives. Before joining Spring Health, Karishma led teams at OppFi, overseeing People, Communications, and Customer Success and driving critical business transformation initiatives. She has also built talent management initiatives at Groupon and BAE Systems. Karishma holds a Bachelor's degree in Psychology from the University of Virginia and a Doctorate in Clinical Psychology from the Georgia School of Professional Psychology, with internship and fellowship completed at the University of Pennsylvania Health System.

    About the clinical reviewer
    photo authr

    Stay connected to the latest in mental health!

    Our newsletter delivers expert insights, personal stories, and practical strategies straight to your inbox. Join us to better support your team’s mental health.